Bowker Vs. Paul

With the recent wavier claim on Xavier Paul, it was only a matter time of before the Pirates had to make a move on the 25 man roster to make way for him. Many had speculated that the move might be to send Steve Pearce down, as he had an option left. The second thought was that they might designate John Bowker to make room. Well Neal Huntington chose option 2 and designated John Bowker for assignment.

It is strange that Huntington made this move, he typically goes on the side of caution and I would have bet good money he would have sent Pearce down as that would have allowed them to keep all players. Granted Bowker might clear waivers and if so we still keep him, but there is a risk involved now.

In adding Paul the Pirates are adding a player with a broader offensive skill set than perhaps what Bowker brought to the table, but maybe not as much potential, as Bowker had some pop in his bat, though we did not see much of it. Paul has some pop, but also brings speed to the table and flexibility at all outfield positions.

It is the defensive flexibility that I think ruled the day with this move. Steve Pearce has picked up playing 3rd base. He already plays first and can play right at PNC. Also in right the Pirates have Garrett Jones and Matt Diaz. The team seemed to pigeon hole Bowker in the corner outfield role, which would put him 3rd on the depth chart. Adding Paul gives them a back up to McCutchen and Tabata.

It is my thought that Bowker got designated then because of his defensive 'flaws'. With Pearce playing third it has added to his value and gives Clint Hurdle another option. If anything we have learned in the first month, Clint Hurdle likes to juggle things around. Having guys able to play all over, fit his type of style.

It remains to be seen though if Xavier Paul can handle big league pitching, but he brings other elements to the table that make him an attractive bench option. In the grand scheme of things this all really does not matter, as Bowker for Paul is not going to cost the team the pennant, but it does perhaps show a higher emphasis on flexibiliyt and broader skill sets for players.