Monday, April 25, 2011

Debut of Wood

Now that Brandon Wood has made his debut, and did so driving in a few runs, many will now place some unfair expectations on him. Not necessarily anyone who pays attention to baseball, but if you have a passing interest someone may think that the Pirates made a steal. In fact I am going to make a predication that in some office in the Pittsburgh area, around the water cooler, some idiot will say something like the following, "Good thing Wood got those RBI's. We can now trade him like the rest of them now that he is worth something."

I am sure that statement will be said by someone. I can almost predict that it will happen in my office. What the real statement should be is, what exactly are we doing with Brandon Wood? Is he here to rest Pedro Alvarez and Neil Walker? Tonight for example, he played third, as a lefty John Lannan was on the mound. Alvarez being left handed was sat in place of Wood.

Now Pedro Alvarez has struggled in the early going, but had hit a home run before returning to Pittsburgh and had shown signs of getting on track. Now we sit him against an average lefty for Brandon Wood? I am sure that this will happen at some point with Neil Walker as well. Riddle me this then, are we better off trotting out Pedro Alvarez game after game or giving Brandon Wood a shot? I think the answer is obvious.

If we want to see Wood play, then play him at short. See if he can still play it. If not, then let him settle in as a utility guy. Any ballplayer can be a utility guy. Why not see if Wood can still hack it before settling him somewhere, but do it not at the expense of a cornerstone of the future in Pedro Alvarez.

2 comments:

The Voice said...

I was stunned to see they sat Pedro for him. I mean it's not like Ronny Cedeno is tearing it up. No brainer, start the kid at SS! He can't be much worse.

WilliamJPellas said...

I would normally agree with you, The Voice, but I think Pedro is in trouble. He's always been a slow starter, to be sure, but I pointed out elsewhere in the blogosphere that he got the bulk of his production last season in garbage time, ie, in September, when a lot (though by no means all) of his action was against other teams' end of season callups.

Don't get me wrong, I'm sure he will still be a better than average power hitter before it's all said and done. But if he doesn't become the kind of hitter who is launching 30 or more bombs ever year, he isn't going to help you much. He won't hit for a particulary high average, he can't play third base (though I'm sure he'd be okay at first), and he can't steal bases. There's also the possibility that he'll eat his way out of the big leagues, though so far---very much to his credit---he's been in good shape for such a big guy.

Anyway, I think he is headed back to Triple A for a 6 week wakeup call, and that might happen sooner rather than later.